LegalReader.com  ·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

News & Politics

Music Industry May Have Sued Wrong Person


— September 24, 2003

In a possible case of mistaken identity, the recording industry has withdrawn a lawsuit against a 66-year-old sculptor who claims never to have even downloaded song-sharing software, let alone used it.

Sarah Seabury Ward, of Newbury, Mass., and her husband use their computer to e-mail with children and grandchildren, said Electronic Frontier Foundation attorney Cindy Cohn, who has worked with the family. They use a Macintosh, which cannot even run the Kazaa file-sharing service they are accused of using illegally. . . .

[A]n attorney for the Recording Industry Association of America withdrew the case Friday, calling the move a “gesture of good faith” but writing in a letter to Ward’s attorney that the organization would continue to look into the matter and reserved the right to refile.

The story’s here from the AP via FindLaw.


In a possible case of mistaken identity, the recording industry has withdrawn a lawsuit against a 66-year-old sculptor who claims never to have even downloaded song-sharing software, let alone used it.

Sarah Seabury Ward, of Newbury, Mass., and her husband use their computer to e-mail with children and grandchildren, said Electronic Frontier Foundation attorney Cindy Cohn, who has worked with the family. They use a Macintosh, which cannot even run the Kazaa file-sharing service they are accused of using illegally. . . .

[A]n attorney for the Recording Industry Association of America withdrew the case Friday, calling the move a “gesture of good faith” but writing in a letter to Ward’s attorney that the organization would continue to look into the matter and reserved the right to refile.

The story’s here from the AP via FindLaw.

Join the conversation!