A recall was announced due to concerns over hidden chemical contamination.
Disposable paper plates are often seen as a simple solution for parties, busy weeknights, and large gatherings. They promise easy cleanup and less hassle, which is why they are found in many homes. However, over the past several years, concerns have grown about what some of these plates may contain. Safety actions, testing reports, and lawsuits have raised questions about whether certain disposable plates carry harmful substances that could end up in food.
One of the most direct safety actions involved children’s bamboo plates sold by the retailer Primark. These plates were marketed toward kids and featured playful designs like animals and cartoon-style images. In 2023, testing found that some of these products contained lead and formaldehyde at levels considered unsafe for children. Lead is known to be especially harmful to young bodies, as it can interfere with brain growth and learning over time. Formaldehyde can also pose health risks if it migrates into food. After these findings, the plates were pulled from shelves and families were told to stop using them right away.
Other cases have not involved official recalls but still caused public concern. Chinet, a well-known brand of disposable paper plates, became the focus of a class action lawsuit tied to chemicals known as PFAS. These chemicals are sometimes added to paper products to make them resist grease and moisture. PFAS are often called “forever chemicals” because they break down very slowly in the environment. The lawsuit claimed that some plates were labeled as compostable or eco-friendly even though they contained these substances. While regulators did not issue a recall, the case highlighted how chemical content can clash with green marketing claims.
Store-brand products have also come under scrutiny. Nature’s Promise, a brand that sells molded fiber plates advertised as tree-free and earth-friendly, was flagged during independent testing. Lab results suggested high levels of fluorine, which is often used as a sign that PFAS may be present. These findings raised concerns that chemicals could move from the plate into hot or greasy foods. Even without an official recall, such reports can influence how shoppers view these products and whether retailers keep them on shelves.
Kroger has faced similar legal challenges related to its disposable plates and bowls. A lawsuit filed several years ago claimed that some of these items contained PFAS while being sold as safe for food use and compostable. Like other cases, this did not result in a government recall. Still, it added to a growing number of complaints suggesting that chemical coatings may be more common in paper foodware than many people realize.
Beyond individual brands, studies and reports from advocacy groups have found that PFAS are widespread in paper-based food packaging. These chemicals help keep plates from soaking through, but they also raise environmental and health concerns. Some states have responded by passing laws that limit or ban the added use of PFAS in food packaging. California, for example, has taken steps to restrict these chemicals, pushing manufacturers to change materials or formulas.
The lack of a recall does not always mean a product is free from risk. Many items remain on the market even after testing shows signs of chemical treatment. This gap between testing results and formal action can leave consumers unsure about what is safe. Labels such as “eco-friendly” or “compostable” do not always guarantee that a plate is free from harmful coatings, especially if clear certification is missing.
As awareness grows, shoppers are starting to pay closer attention to what disposable paper plates are made of and how they are labeled. Some choose alternatives that clearly state they are PFAS-free, while others return to reusable options when possible. The issue has shown that convenience products can carry hidden costs, especially when safety testing lags behind marketing claims. Disposable plates may still serve a purpose, but the recent cases show the importance of transparency and careful review of everyday items that come into contact with food.
Sources:
5 paper plates pulled from store shelves for toxic contamination
Join the conversation!