LegalReader.com  ·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

News & Politics

How is a Holographic Will Proved Valid in California Courts?


— February 7, 2023

Holographic wills are not exempt from testamentary capacity to execute a will.


Holographic wills can be considered valid in California courts. Despite the common requirements of a last will and testament prepared for the purposes of transferring assets that include the person making the will, referred to as the testator, to sign the document and have witnesses sign it who are present at the same time, and who personally witness either the signing of the will or the testator’s acknowledgment of the signature or of the will, handwritten wills (holographic) may be considered valid in court.  California estate planning lawyers can assist surviving loved ones and beneficiaries with the questions surrounding a holographic will document. The importance of a will is that it explains where and how an individual would like their assets divided, debts resolved and end of life issues outlined in detail as they are very personal matters. Oakland estate planning lawyers guide clients to make sure a will contains the legally necessary language so a person’s wishes can be honored at the time of their death according to California and federal laws. 

Will validation

California law states that a holographic will is valid and enforceable so long as the material provisions of the will and the signature are in the handwriting of the testator. There is no requirement for witnesses, acknowledgements, or other formalities. A holographic will also does not even need to be dated. A holographic serves the same function as a formal typewritten will, naming executors and determining which assets go to which beneficiary, among other things. Holographic wills are far more open to a validity challenge than wills meeting the formal will signing requirements. A holographic will needs to establish by some evidence that it is written in the handwriting of the testator. If a date is not present, then any inconsistency between the holographic will and the provisions of another dated will are decided in favor of the dated will. Holographic wills are only exempt from the signing requirements of a formal will. 

Testamentary capacity

Photo by Bicanski, courtesy of Pixnio.com. CC0

Holographic wills are not exempt from testamentary capacity to execute a will. Everyone who makes any kind of will document must have testamentary capacity at the time they sign their will. Holographic wills that are not dated can make it harder to prove testamentary capacity if the testator signed a holographic will without a date, but then later developed dementia or Alzheimer’s, the will may not survive a challenge.

Seek legal counsel

California courts can find holographic wills to be enforceable but they should only be used when the formality surrounding a properly executed will cannot be followed.  Consultation with a lawyer is important to understand the distinction between formally written wills and holographic wills.  It is best to hire estate planning lawyers to draft essential documentation to minimize legal challenges to a deceased’s estate. Consultation with tax lawyers  is also a prudent decision so they can review estate planning documents and explain how tax burdens on the estate or beneficiaries will be managed.

Sources:

  1. https://www.courts.ca.gov/8865.htm?rdeLocaleAttr=en
  2. Law section (ca.gov)
  3. Law section (ca.gov)

Join the conversation!