·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Mental Health

Individual Interventions are Unable Employee Well-being

— January 26, 2024

New research challenges individual-level options to improve workplace satisfaction.

In the quest to enhance workplace well-being, businesses are increasingly turning to interventions at both individual and organizational levels. A recent study, featured in the Industrial Relations Journal, challenges the effectiveness of individual-level mental well-being interventions, such as mindfulness, resilience and stress management, relaxation classes, and well-being apps. Conducted by William Fleming, Ph.D., from the Well-being Research Center at the University of Oxford, the research scrutinized survey data from 46,336 workers in 233 organizations across the U.K.

Surprisingly, the findings revealed no substantive evidence supporting the positive impact of individual-level interventions on employees’ well-being. Participants engaging in these interventions did not exhibit significantly better outcomes across multiple subjective well-being indicators when compared to their counterparts who did not partake. This calls for a reevaluation of the prevailing emphasis on individual-level strategies.

Dr. Fleming highlighted the necessity for a shift towards organizational interventions, advocating for changes in scheduling, management practices, staff resources, performance reviews, and job design. According to him, the study’s broad scope, including diverse workplaces, provides a valuable contrast to trials often confined to a single organization.

In light of the prevailing consensus indicating that enhancing employee well-being necessitates a transformation in the workplace rather than a sole focus on individual employees, Dr. Fleming expressed the need for more ambitious strategies. The absence of discernible benefits from individual-level interventions highlights the urgency for comprehensive approaches to foster well-being in the professional world.

Individual Interventions are Unable Employee Well-being
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio from Pexels

This study challenges the prevailing narrative surrounding mental health interventions and seeks to ignite further research and proactive measures by employers. As organizations go through the evolving technicalities of employee well-being, this research signals the potential limitations of exclusive reliance on individual-level approaches, urging a broader, systemic perspective for sustained positive outcomes.

While individual-level interventions may lack the anticipated impact, organizations are encouraged to explore a more comprehensive approach. Shifting the focus towards systemic changes in the workplace, such as flexible scheduling, supportive management practices, adequate staff resources, fair performance reviews, and thoughtful job design, could yield more significant improvements in employee well-being.

The study prompts a reconsideration of workplace well-being initiatives, emphasizing the need for a holistic approach. Organizations should look beyond individual interventions and consider integrated strategies that address both individual and organizational factors.

This broader perspective is crucial for creating a work environment that genuinely supports the well-being of every employee. This study challenges long-standing traditions that have often centered on individual-level mental well-being interventions in the professional sphere.

Traditionally, businesses and organizations have frequently turned to approaches such as mindfulness programs, resilience training, stress management initiatives, relaxation classes, and well-being apps to enhance the mental health of their employees. These interventions have been considered part of a standard toolkit aimed at promoting a healthier and more productive workforce.

The lack of discernible benefits across various well-being indicators suggests a need for a reevaluation of these traditional strategies. Instead, the study advocates for a shift in focus towards organizational-level interventions that address broader workplace structures and practices.


Study finds no evidence that individual-level mental health interventions improve employees’ well-being

Employee well-being outcomes from individual-level mental health interventions: Cross-sectional evidence from the United Kingdom 

Promoting employee wellbeing and preventing non-clinical mental health problems in the workplace: a preparatory consultation survey

Join the conversation!