·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Lawsuits & Litigation

Kentucky Lawmakers Accused of Sexual Harassment Want Settlement Money Back

— February 1, 2019

In a surprising turn from the #MeToo movement’s norms, former Kentucky state Rep. Jeff Hoover, accused of sexual harassment, is demanding that his settlement be paid back in full–with interest.

After winning upwards of $110,000 in a sexual harassment settlement, accused Kentucky lawmakers are demanding that the woman pay them back for violating a confidentiality agreement.

The settlement, writes, led to the resignation of former Kentucky House Speaker Jeff Hoover. Hoover, a Republican, was accused of harassment at the height of the #metoo movement.

While the self-proclaimed family man eventually resigned in reaction to the abuse allegations, he’s now pushing back.

Hoover attorney Leslie Vose, along with state Rep. Michael Meredith and former state Rep. Jim DeCesare, says the lawmakers signed a settlement with the woman “in good faith.” It included a confidentiality agreement as well as a stipulation that its signatories refuse comment when or if asked about the circumstances.

Vose claims the woman told two coworkers about the settlement, violating its provisions.

The two workers, House GOP Communications Director Daisy Olivo and House Clerk Brad Metcalf, were fired in the scandal’s aftermath. says the two have since filed whistleblower lawsuits, claiming they were punished for bringing wrongdoing into the public sphere.

“[The woman] breached that agreement and ignored her legal obligation, and we think she should be held accountable,” Vose said in an e-mail to the Associated Press. Because of her choice to abandon the agreement, Vose claims the politicians “have sustained damage to their reputations, in continuing legal fees and costs, mental anguish, paid moneys under a fraudulently induced settlement, and have not received any of the confidentiality they were promised.”

The woman’s attorney, Gail Langendorf, said he client specifically asked not to be named.

Self-proclaimed “family man” and former Kentucky Majority Leader Jeff Hoover. Image via Flickr/user:Gage Skidmore. (CCA-BY-2.0).

However, she claims that the settlement should have been a matter of public record anyway—and that former lawmakers like Hoover have no business trying to recoup the settlement’s costs.

“This is nothing more than continued harassment of my client by the people she was sexually harassed by,’ Langendorf said. “It’s ridiculous.”

Hoover, notes, is the only one of the accused who’s spoken publicly about the settlement. He maintains that he sent sexually explicit but otherwise consensual text messages to the woman.

The messages were made public as part of an investigation by the Legislative Ethics Commission. If anything, they seem either ambiguous to or supportive of Hoover’s position—in one back-and-forth, the woman asks Hoover to “come over” for a night. He declined, asking instead that she send a suggestive photograph.

“Shortly after my client declined her inappropriate invitation, the texting between them ceased,” Vose said.

In line with the texts, Hoover says whatever he did wasn’t ‘unwelcome.’ But in a deposition, the woman claims that he made at least 50 unwanted sexual advances, including groping her in public spaces and touching her underneath meeting tables.

She says that none of the encounters were consensual, but she felt pressured into silence because Hoover was her boss.

Hoover, for his part, admitted to a violation of legislative ethics code for acting inappropriately and was fined $1,000 by the chamber.


Kentucky lawmakers seek return of sexual harassment payment

Hoover sues former staffer, wants money back in sexual harassment deal

Join the conversation!