·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

News & Politics

Medical Bills Piling Up? How to Fight Back Against Surprise Costs

— March 26, 2024

Use the resources available, stand up for yourself, and regain peace of mind when it comes to your medical care.

Surprise medical bills are a nightmare, turning what should be routine healthcare into a financial crisis. You might feel helpless and overwhelmed, unsure of where to even begin fighting back.  But know this: you do have rights, and there are strategies to dispute these exorbitant charges.  Understanding your options and taking proactive steps can make all the difference. Whether you need the experience of a New York personal injury lawyer to guide you or just clearer information, this article will equip you with the knowledge you need to challenge those bills and protect your hard-earned money. 

Understanding Surprise Medical Bills

Surprise medical bills are a frustrating and often confusing reality of the American healthcare system. They occur when a patient receives unexpected charges for medical services, usually due to complex billing arrangements and out-of-network issues. You might encounter scenarios such as: receiving treatment from an out-of-network doctor at an in-network hospital, unexpected facility fees, or balance billing (when providers charge more than your insurer’s allowed amount). Surprise bills can leave patients with thousands of dollars in unanticipated medical debt, causing significant financial and emotional hardship.

Know Your Rights: The No Surprises Act

The No Surprises Act is a federal law designed to protect patients from surprise medical bills in specific situations. It took effect in January 2022 and offers significant safeguards.  Key provisions include protection from out-of-network charges in emergencies, limits on out-of-network charges at in-network facilities, and an independent dispute resolution process for patients to challenge unexpected bills.

Specifically, the Act protects you in these ways: You cannot be charged more than your in-network cost-sharing amounts (like deductibles or co-pays) for emergency services, even if you receive treatment from an out-of-network provider.  Additionally, if you have a planned procedure at an in-network hospital or facility, out-of-network providers (like anesthesiologists) cannot bill you without your consent. Lastly, the Act provides a way for patients and providers to settle payment disputes through an independent arbitrator.

Vacuum cleaner sucking up dollar bills; image by RegularGuy.eth, via
Vacuum cleaner sucking up dollar bills; image by RegularGuy.eth, via

However, understand that the Act has limitations. It may not cover all surprise billing scenarios, such as those arising from billing disputes completely within your insurance network or from ground ambulance services.

Before You Get Treated: Protecting Yourself

The best way to avoid surprise medical bills is by being proactive. Here’s what you need to do:

  • Know Your Insurance: Thoroughly understand your insurance plan. Are your regular doctors in-network? Which hospitals and facilities are covered? What are your deductibles and co-pays? Call your insurance company for clarification if needed.
  • Choose In-Network Providers: Whenever possible, choose doctors and facilities within your insurance network. This minimizes the risk of out-of-network charges. Check your insurance directory or contact the provider directly.
  • Get Cost Estimates: Before non-emergency procedures, request a pre-treatment cost estimate from your doctor and hospital. Ask your insurer about their estimated coverage. Put these estimates in writing.

When You Receive a Surprise Bill: Taking Action

Receiving a surprise bill can be a shock, but it’s important to remain calm and take action. Here’s what to do:

  • Scrutinize Thoroughly: Carefully review the bill for errors. Check for incorrect dates, services not rendered, or duplicate charges.
  • Contact the Provider and Insurer: Call your provider’s billing department and your insurance company for clarification. Was there a billing error? Why were certain charges not covered?
  • Start Documenting: Keep detailed notes of your conversations with dates, contact names, and agreed-upon actions. Save all correspondence and medical records.

Negotiation Strategies: Getting What You Deserve

If your bill has questionable charges, don’t simply accept it. Negotiate, using these strategies:

  • Be Prepared: Gather your supporting documentation, including your insurance plan details, pre-treatment estimates, and explanation of benefits (EOB) from your insurer.
  • Highlight Errors: Point out any billing errors or discrepancies between the pre-treatment estimate and the actual charges.
  • Fair Market Value: Research fair market values for the procedures you received, (websites like Healthcare Bluebook: can help). This can strengthen your case for a lower cost.
  • Communicate Clearly: Be firm but respectful when negotiating. Explain your financial situation and why you believe the charges should be reduced. Consider requesting a payment plan if needed.

Seeking External Help: Resources and Support

Sometimes, resolving surprise medical bills requires more than self-advocacy. Here are resources for further help:

  • Patient Advocacy Groups: Organizations dedicated to healthcare affordability and patient rights offer information and assistance. They may help you understand your bills and negotiate with providers.
  • Medical Billing Advocates: These professionals specialize in deciphering complex medical bills, identifying errors, and negotiating with providers and insurers.
  • Legal Aid: If the situation is complex or involves a significant financial burden, legal help may be necessary. Nonprofit legal aid organizations or affordable attorneys could provide counsel and represent you in disputes.


Surprise medical bills can be daunting, but knowledge and action are your best defenses. Understanding your rights, being proactive about your coverage, and fighting back when necessary puts you back in control. Don’t let these bills ruin your health or your finances. Use the resources available, stand up for yourself, and regain peace of mind when it comes to your medical care. If the complexity of the situation feels overwhelming, remember that specialized professionals like medical billing advocates and attorneys can offer guidance and advocate on your behalf.

Join the conversation!