LegalReader.com  ·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Lawsuits & Litigation

A Practical Guide to Handling Insurance Disputes


— December 15, 2025

Knowing your policy and when to seek help means you’ll be able to deal with a dispute more confidently and get the coverage you’ve been paying for.


Insurance is supposed to offer peace of mind, but when a claim is denied or delayed, it can all feel overwhelming. It doesn’t matter if it’s about property damage, medical bills or a car accident, the process is often far more complicated than you first think. Policies are full of jargon, claims have strict deadlines, and insurers often investigate more aggressively than you anticipate. 

In just one sector and one state (Alabama), more than one-third of medical insurance claims were denied in 2023. If you’re experiencing a dispute, here are some practical steps to take to protect your rights and strengthen your case.

Understand What Your Policy Covers

When it comes to insurance, many people don’t read the details of their policy. Your documents will contain a declarations page, coverage sections, exclusions, and definitions. Read these carefully, and pay attention to deadlines, documentation requirements, and instructions for what to do. If something is unclear, contact your insurer and get any clarification you need in writing to create a paper trail that may help you later on.

Document Everything

No matter the claim, be sure to keep and document everything. Receipts, photos, videos, repair estimates, medical reports, or anything else that supports your claim. Keep notes of conversations as well. Write down who you spoke to and when, and summarize what was discussed. If your insurer asks for anything, respond promptly and save copies of every document you send them. Having a well-organized file shows you’re serious and prepared. 

Look Out for Delay or Denial Tactics

Not all insurance companies and disputes involve bad faith. Sometimes, there will be a genuine misunderstanding. However, insurers occasionally use the following strategies to disadvantage policyholders:

Red denied stamp; image by tswedensky, via Pixabay.com.
Red denied stamp; image by tswedensky, via Pixabay.com.
  • Requesting the same documents repeatedly 
  • Delaying inspections
  • Offering low settlements without proper justification 
  • Misinterpreting policy language
  • Claiming evidence is “insufficient” and not explaining why

If something doesn’t feel right, ask for an explanation in writing. Insurers must give clear reasons why they’re not paying out or why there’s a delay.

Appeal in Writing

If your claim is denied (or even if it’s underpaid), you have the right to appeal. You should do this in writing. The insurer’s letter should explain why your claim was rejected and what evidence was considered when they rejected it. Use this to prepare a response. 

Include supporting documents, expert reports, and additional photos. Keep your tone professional. Be factual, not emotional. Many disputes do get resolved after an initial internal appeal. This is especially true if you present strong evidence. 

Know When to Contact a Professional 

Insurance disputes aren’t often best handled alone. If the insurers refuse to budge or they’ve misinterpreted the policy in their favor, it’s time to get advice. At this point, a Houston insurance claims attorney can make a difference to you. 

These specialists know how insurers operate, and they know how to use evidence to push back when a company isn’t meeting its legal obligations. For example, in complex cases like large property losses, denied medical claims, or allegations of fraud, expert representation often helps you get a more favorable outcome. 

Endnote

Insurance disputes aren’t quick things to get resolved. Being organized and responding promptly shows the insurer you are paying attention. Persistence is often what determines whether a dispute resolves fairly. Knowing your policy and when to seek help means you’ll be able to deal with a dispute more confidently and get the coverage you’ve been paying for.

Join the conversation!