LegalReader.com  ·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Lawsuits & Litigation

Concussion Car Accident Settlement: Understanding Pain and Suffering Calculations


— July 9, 2025

By understanding how pain and suffering are calculated, you can effectively pursue a settlement that will help you regain health, cover lost wages, and support your long-term needs.


Car accidents can be life-altering events, mainly when they result in head injuries like concussions or traumatic brain injuries (TBI). These injuries often have lasting effects that go beyond immediate physical harm, potentially causing cognitive issues, emotional distress, and financial strain. Many victims don’t realize the full impact of their injury until weeks or months after the accident, when symptoms persist or worsen.  

When a concussion occurs, it’s not just a simple bump on the head – it’s a serious medical condition that can develop long-term complications. Unfortunately, insurance companies frequently underestimate these challenges when calculating settlement offers for injury cases.  

Here’s what you need to know about concussion settlements in car accidents and how pain and suffering are compensated.

How Concussions and TBIs Affect Settlement Value  

Working with the best personal injury lawyer in San Fernando or your location can make a crucial difference in how your brain injury claim is valued. For instance, a concussion may be considered mild, but its effects can be long-lasting. Many victims develop Post-Concussion Syndrome (PCS), which can cause persistent concussion symptoms such as headaches, dizziness, memory loss, and cognitive impairments. In severe cases, diffuse axonal injury or coup-contrecoup injury may occur, leading to permanent damage to brain tissue.  

Since insurance company tactics often involve downplaying these injuries, strong medical evidence is essential. This includes:  

  • Medical records detailing diagnostic tests (CT scans, MRIs, brain imaging)  
  • Neuropsychological testing to assess cognitive ability  
  • Symptom tracking logs to document ongoing issues  
  • Medical research supporting your diagnosis (e.g., second impact syndrome or autonomic nervous system dysfunction)  

Because the full impact of a concussion may not be immediately apparent, having an experienced personal injury attorney build your case with thorough medical documentation is essential to ensuring your settlement reflects the actual long-term consequences of your injury.

Factors That Influence Concussion Settlement Ranges

Several key factors determine the settlement value of a head injury claim:

1. Severity

The settlement value depends on whether the concussion is classified as mild, moderate, or severe. While mild traumatic brain injuries (mTBIs) may resolve with minimal treatment, cases involving Post-Concussion Syndrome (PCS) or chronic symptoms often justify higher compensation due to prolonged recovery periods, ongoing therapy needs, and potential permanent limitations.

Severe TBIs—such as those involving diffuse axonal injury or structural brain damage—typically result in the highest settlements, as they frequently require lifelong medical care and drastically alter a victim’s quality of life.  

2. Medical Documentation

A well-documented medical history is critical for proving the extent of your injuries. This includes emergency room records, diagnostic imaging (CT/MRI scans), neurologist reports, and detailed notes from follow-up visits. Consistent documentation of symptoms—such as headaches, memory lapses, or mood changes—strengthens the connection between the accident and your condition. Gaps in treatment or incomplete records, however, can be exploited by insurers to dispute your claim’s validity or downplay its severity.  

3. Impact on Daily Life

Pain Relievers May Speed Concussion Recovery
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio from Pexels

Compensation isn’t just about medical bills; it also accounts for how the injury disrupts your personal and professional life. Many victims miss work hours, lose earning capacity, and become unable to perform daily activities due to their injuries. Meanwhile, non-economic damages—like pain, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life—are harder to quantify but often comprise a substantial portion of the final settlement, especially in cases with lasting disabilities.  

4. Insurance Policy Limits

Even with a strong claim, the at-fault party’s insurance coverage acts as a financial ceiling. If their policy limits are low (e.g., state minimums), your potential recovery may be capped unless additional coverage (like underinsured motorist protection) applies. An experienced attorney can identify all available sources of compensation, including personal assets or umbrella policies, to maximize your settlement when policy limits are insufficient.  

By carefully evaluating these factors with legal and medical experts, you can build a compelling case that reflects the actual financial, physical, and emotional costs of your concussion injury.  

How Pain and Suffering Is Calculated  

As pain and suffering are subjective, insurers often use the below to quantify it:  

  • The multiplier method: Total economic damages (medical bills + lost wages) multiplied by a factor (1.5x–5x) based on injury severity.  
  • The per diem approach: Assigning a daily rate for each day you suffer symptoms.  

A TBI settlement calculator can provide estimates, but an experienced personal injury law firm will negotiate for the highest possible compensation.  

Why You Need a Skilled Personal Injury Lawyer  

The process of handling insurance matters post-accident can quickly become daunting for injury victims. A personal injury lawyer can:  

  • Gather medical evidence and diagnostic tests to prove your brain injury claim  
  • Counteract insurance company tactics that minimize your settlement amount  
  • Ensure compensation for all incurred damages  
  • Accurately factor in future medical costs and lost earning potential  
  • Handle all legal paperwork and deadlines to protect your claim  
  • Negotiate with multiple insurance providers if needed  

With so much at stake, having an expert advocate in concussion cases can mean the difference between an inadequate offer and full compensation for your injuries.  

Conclusion

If you’re struggling with concussion injuries or post-concussion syndrome, don’t accept the first lowball offer. Consult a personal injury attorney to help you with the settlement process and fight for what you deserve. By understanding how pain and suffering are calculated, you can effectively pursue a settlement that will help you regain health, cover lost wages, and support your long-term needs.

Join the conversation!