·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Featured Article

Bleeding Kansas, Gosar, and What’s Next

— November 22, 2021

As clashes ratchet up and a stark ideological divide appears irreconcilable, is Portland the new Bleeding Kansas on our road to Civil War v2.0?

America’s first Civil War didn’t spring fully formed from the forehead of Robert E. Lee. From Bleeding Kansas to the caning of Charles Sumner to John Brown’s attack on Harper’s Ferry, clues littered the road leading to the war that took 750,000 American lives, a number we only recently surpassed in COVID dead. With last Friday marking the 158th anniversary of Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address and tensions running high in the wake of Kyle Rittenhouse’s acquittal in Kenosha, it’s increasingly possible that we’re not only repaving the road, but we’re reaching a Bleeding Kansas level of hostility in the soi-disant United States today.

On May 26th, 2017, a man on a Portland, OR, commuter train began harassing two young women, one of whom was wearing a hijab. As he became increasingly unhinged, three bystanders stepped in to defuse the situation. Two of them, Ricky Best and Taliesin Namkai-Meche, died after the attacker, a white supremacist, whipped out a knife and stabbed them in the neck. The third, Micah David-Cole Fletcher, survived. The incident landed a spotlight on Portland, a city that would continue to play host to repeated clashes between far right groups and anti-fascists, like a modern-day Bleeding Kansas.

In 2019, another young man, Sean Kealiher, was killed outside a Portland bar frequented by local leftists, a death that Portland police have been slow to investigate. In contrast, when anti-fascist Michael Reinoehl shot and killed Patriot Prayer supporter Aaron Danielson as he took part in a pro-Trump caravan through Black Lives Matter protests in Portland in 2020, U.S. marshals tracked Reinoehl down and shot him to death as he was getting into his car, no trial needed. The hotter it gets in today’s Bleeding Kansas, the more it attracts right wing extremists from around the United States to fight in the streets and put the smackdown on sign-carrying Black Lives Matter protesters, street medics, and journalists, violence and gunfights turning into guerilla warfare as police stand aside.

In May of 1856, Charles Sumner, an anti-slavery Senator from Massachusetts, addressed Congress on the matter of Kansas and mocking the opposition as engaging in harlotry with the mistress “Slavery,” who, however ugly to others, is always lovely to them. Days later, House Rep Preston Brooks walked into the Senate chamber and beat Sumner bloody with his metal-tipped cane. As Brooks pounded Sumner’s skull over and over, Sumner flailed around until he fell, unmoving, and had to be carried away. Both Sumner and Brooks became heroes for their causes.

A middle-aged man in a brown jacket in front of a draped American flag.
U.S. Congressman Paul Gosar. Photo by Gage Skidmore, via Flickr. CC BY-SA 2.0

Last week, Rep. Paul Gosar (R-AZ) was censured by the House of Representatives after making a social media post showing a cartoon video of himself killing fellow House Rep Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) and slashing at President Biden with a sword. The vote to censure Gosar fell along party lines with only two Republicans joining Democrats to rebuke Gosar. As Gosar stood in the House well during the reading of the censure, he was joined in support by fellow Republicans Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA), Andy Biggs (R-AZ), and Lauren Boebert (R-CO). Immediately afterward, he retweeted the video. (A day later, Trump endorsed him.) Perhaps we should be glad that Gosar stopped at bad animé instead of going full Preston Brooks on AOC. So far.

How far down this road will we go? The Capitol has already been invaded by Confederate flag-waving insurgents bent on defending the country from a thing that didn’t happen. The Kyle Rittenhouse verdict will not improve relations in a country so polarized between those seeking equality for Black lives and an economic system that provides something other than misery for the working class and poor, and a surging right wing who see these as existential threats to the American way of life (and Rittenhouse as the vigilante hero they’ve been waiting for). It’s an ideological rift that isn’t entirely different from the one that caused North and South to fight so bitterly – and so bloodily – all those years ago.

Related: A Cold Civil War is Still Being Fought


The Caning of Senator Charles Sumner

House censures Gosar, removes him from committees

Trump endorses Gosar one day after House censure

The Outsized Meaning of the Rittenhouse Verdict

Rittenhouse acquittal magnifies divisions in a polarized America

Right-Wing Activists, White Supremacists Celebrate Rittenhouse Acquittal

Here’s What We Know About The Suspect In The Portland Train Stabbing Attack

Portland, Oregon, Is Ground Zero for Violent Culture-War Clashes. And It’s Spreading

Hundreds clash in Portland as Proud Boys rally descends into violence

Join the conversation!