·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Lawsuits & Litigation

California Inmates Sue State, Share Stories of Mice, Maggots in Food

— April 11, 2019

The state says it’ll dedicate some money to fixing up its prisons, but blames inmates for the problems.

A California inmate is suing the state, claiming it hasn’t acted fast enough to keep its prisons in good repair.

According to the Los Angeles Times, California has committed $260 million to repair ‘leaking roofs and clear dangerous mold at more than two dozen deteriorating prisons.’ But that quarter-billion investment doesn’t meet expectations. Bringing the state’s jails up to par would run closer to an even $1 billion.

The lawsuit, filed by inmate Robert Escareno, provides a disturbing fist-hand look at conditions in state prisons. His allegations have been backed up by other convicts, including Marvin Dominguez, who provided corroborating accounts full of disgusting details.

Dominguez claims, among other things, that maggots and mice are common fixtures at some facilities. He says they sometimes fall through the ceiling, dropping onto inmates’ dining tables.

The same faulty infrastructure that allows rodents and insects to infiltrate also means that bird droppings and rain make their way through roof, streaking walls and dampening floors.

Recounting the suit’s specifics, the Los Angeles Times reports that mice ‘twice fell onto a dining table and scurried into a dishwashing area in April 2018.’ Dominguez, who eats twice a day at the California Substance Abuse Treatment Facility and State Prison in Corcoran, claims he’s also found writhing maggots in his lunch tray.

A 2013 image of current California Gov.–then Attorney General–Gavin Newsom. Newsom has dedicated some funds to renovating state prisons. Recently, he garnered some controversy after granting reprieves to all of the state’s death row prisoners. Image via Flickr/user:JD Lasica. (CCA-BY-2.0).

When he tried to complain, a guard advised Dominguez to try sitting at another table.

Escareno, for his part, says he’s had to eat in dining halls decorated with bird dung. Combined with mold and an assortment of other organic contaminants, the inmate says he has a hard time controlling his allergies.

“We all know that prison is not supported to be comfortable,” Escareno told the presiding judge, “but at the same time, it’s not designed for me to have to go and eat in a place where I’m feet away from what I know to be bird feces.”

Photographs republished by the Associated Press align with inmates’ claims. Ceiling tiles appear water-damaged, broken in spots and completely absent in others.

And other pictures, showing roofing material at a California prison, evidence poor upkeep—corrugated metal, covered in rust and half-buried in rocks.

Corcoran Prison Lt. Michael Owens, testifying on behalf of the state, blamed part of the problem on inmates.

According to Owens, Corcoran suffers from rainwater leaks that break down and destroy interior ceiling tiles. The prison no longer replaces them.

But inmates, alleges Owens, make it even worse. The lieutenant claims that some convicts will toss food into Corcoran’s ventilation system, attracting flies and their offspring.

Owen testified that he’d tried to remedy the problem by making inmates bleach the walls.

However, California officials do seem to recognize that system needs fixing, even if it’s sometimes made worse by inmates themselves.

“Roofs are failing all over the place,” said Don Specter, director of the Prison Law Office, which is representing Escareno. “They acknowledge the need of the roofs, but they’re not making arrangements so people don’t get hurt in the meantime.”


California prison hall’s maggots, mice subject of lawsuit

Inmates’ lawsuit complains of maggots and mice falling from the ceiling into food and bird feces streaking the walls due to California prison’s leaky roof

Inmates sue after maggots, mice fall into prison dining hall in Corcoran

Join the conversation!