·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Lawsuits & Litigation

How Medical Records Can Make or Break an Injury Lawsuit

— July 11, 2023

Injury lawsuits require a strong foundation of evidence, and medical records play a pivotal role in establishing the plaintiff’s case.

Injury lawsuits are complex legal cases that often hinge on the strength of the evidence presented. Among the crucial pieces of evidence in such cases, medical records play a pivotal role. Medical records contain vital information about an individual’s injuries, treatment, and prognosis, and they can significantly impact the outcome of an injury lawsuit. This article explores the importance of medical records in injury lawsuits and how they can make or break a case.

The Role of Medical Records in an Injury Lawsuit

Medical records serve as a fundamental source of evidence in injury lawsuits. They provide a comprehensive overview of the plaintiff’s injuries, the medical treatment received, and the long-term prognosis. When presented in court, medical records help establish the extent of the injuries and the impact they have had on the plaintiff’s life. This evidence is critical in demonstrating the causation between the defendant’s actions or negligence and the plaintiff’s injuries.

Establishing Causation and Damages

Medical records are instrumental in proving causation and damages in an injury lawsuit. They document the initial examination of the injuries, including the medical professional’s observations and assessments. By reviewing the medical records, experts can determine the direct link between the defendant’s actions and the injuries suffered by the plaintiff. This link is crucial in establishing liability and holding the defendant accountable for their actions.

Furthermore, medical records provide detailed information about the treatment received by the plaintiff. This includes medications prescribed, surgeries performed, physical therapy sessions, and any other interventions. The records also document the associated costs, such as hospital bills, rehabilitation expenses, and ongoing medical care. By presenting these records in court, the plaintiff’s legal team can accurately calculate the economic damages resulting from the injuries.

Validating the Severity of Injuries

Medical records also serve to validate the severity of the injuries sustained by the plaintiff. They contain objective information about diagnostic tests, radiology reports, and specialist consultations. These records provide an impartial assessment of the injuries and their impact on the plaintiff’s health and well-being.

Marijuana Users Have More Post-Surgery Pain, Opioid Scripts
Photo by Ba Tik from Pexels

In addition, medical records often include the physician’s prognosis for the future. This information helps establish the long-term consequences of the injuries and the potential need for ongoing medical care or rehabilitation. The court considers such prognosis in determining the non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life. The more comprehensive and well-documented the medical records, the stronger the case for higher compensation.

Challenges with Medical Records

While medical records are invaluable in injury lawsuits, they can also present challenges. One common challenge is the incompleteness or inconsistency of the records. In some cases, medical professionals may fail to document crucial details or overlook certain symptoms. This can create gaps in the evidence and weaken the plaintiff’s case.

Another challenge is the potential bias of the medical providers. Defense attorneys may argue that the treating physicians have a vested interest in supporting the plaintiff’s claim due to financial arrangements or personal relationships. It is crucial for the plaintiff’s legal team to carefully review the medical records, seek expert opinions, and address any potential biases or conflicts of interest.

Injury lawsuits require a strong foundation of evidence, and medical records play a pivotal role in establishing the plaintiff’s case. They provide vital information to validate the causation, severity, and prognosis of the injuries. However, challenges such as incomplete or biased records must be carefully addressed to ensure the strength and reliability of the evidence presented. Therefore, obtaining comprehensive and accurate medical records and working with a spinal cord injury lawyer to help you understand your legal rights is crucial to maximize the chances of success in an injury lawsuit.

Join the conversation!