·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Lawsuits & Litigation

Key Factors Influencing Fair Asset Division in Divorce Cases

— July 12, 2023

Fair asset division in divorce cases is a multifaceted issue impacted by numerous factors.

Beyond the emotional turmoil, the issue of asset division surfaces as a key concern in divorce cases. The concept of a fair distribution of assets is fundamental in ensuring both parties move forward with financial stability. Thus, understanding the various factors influencing this aspect can assist individuals in effectively navigating asset division. 

Given the inherent complexity of this process, the need for obtaining a fair financial settlement or property distribution is paramount. It ensures neither party is disproportionately burdened with debt or left without the resources they contributed to during the marriage.  

This article highlights key factors influencing this division, allowing individuals to understand the landscape better and strive for an equitable resolution. 

  1. Laws Governing Property Division 

The laws governing property division often significantly impact the process, making it the first major factor to consider when obtaining a fair financial settlement. Every jurisdiction has specific rules for dividing marital assets. For instance, some operate under ‘community property’ laws, which view both spouses as equal owners of all marital property. In contrast, others adhere to ‘equitable distribution’ laws, where the court aims for a fair but not necessarily equal division. 

Understanding these laws is crucial as they form the basis upon which the division is carried out. They determine the ownership rights over assets and liabilities, the degree to which individual contributions matter, and how separate and marital property are differentiated. For this reason, it is recommended to seek legal advice in the respective jurisdiction to ensure the accurate application and interpretation of these laws. 

  1. Duration Of The Marriage 

The marriage’s duration can also significantly impact how assets are divided in a divorce. Longer marriages may see an equal split of assets, particularly if both parties contribute equally over time. Shorter marriages might see assets divided based on who brought them into the marriage or who made significant financial contributions during the marriage. 

However, the duration isn’t the only consideration here. The court may also look at each party’s individual needs and circumstances at the time of the divorce. This includes their earning potential, age, health, and other factors that might influence their ability to acquire assets and income in the future. 

  1. Individual Contribution To Marital Property 

The court often evaluates the individual contributions of each spouse towards the acquisition, improvement, or maintenance of the marital property. This includes financial contributions and non-monetary efforts such as home care and child-raising, which indirectly support the ability of the other spouse to earn income. 

This aspect recognizes that marriage is a shared enterprise where both parties contribute differently. Therefore, the court strives to ensure that the non-financial efforts, often undervalued, are recognized during asset division. The goal here is to ensure that neither party walks away feeling short-changed due to the nature of their contributions. 

  1. Economic Circumstances Of Each Spouse 

The economic circumstances of each spouse at the time of the division can also significantly influence the process. This involves evaluating each spouse’s income, earning capacity, employability, and overall financial standing. If one spouse is financially disadvantaged due to sacrificing their career for homemaking or child-rearing, the court might award them a larger portion of the assets. 

The court may also consider the future economic needs of each spouse. This includes the cost of living, potential healthcare needs, and retirement plans. The aim is to prevent a situation where one spouse struggles financially after the divorce due to their economic circumstances. 

  1. Custody Of Children

    Two little girls tending a kids garden patch; image by Mieke Campbell, via
    Two little girls tending a kids garden patch; image by Mieke Campbell, via

The custody of children can be a decisive factor when dividing assets. The court often leans towards ensuring that the children’s living standards do not dramatically change post-divorce. Hence, the parent who gains custody might receive a larger share of the assets, especially the family home, to maintain the children’s lifestyle. 

It’s crucial to note that the court’s primary interest is the welfare of the children. As such, the division of assets may be skewed in favor of their needs. The court also takes into account child support payments, which can influence how the other assets are divided between the spouses. 

  1. Debts And Liabilities 

While the division process largely focuses on assets, debts, and liabilities are equally important. Each party’s individual and joint debt can significantly affect how the assets are split. Often, the court tries to ensure that each party assumes their fair share of the debts. 

The court also considers the ability of each spouse to pay off their assigned debts. If one spouse has a higher income or earning potential, they might be tasked with a larger share of the debts. This process can be complex, particularly when dealing with joint debts, as it involves intricate legal considerations. 

  1. Prenuptial And Postnuptial Agreements 

Prenuptial and postnuptial agreements can be influential factors in the asset division process. These legally binding agreements outline how assets will be divided in the event of a divorce. If such an agreement exists, the court will usually honor it unless it’s proven to be unconscionable or executed under duress. 

It’s important to understand that these agreements can override the standard rules for dividing assets. They allow couples to take control of their financial future, specifying their preferred division approach. However, their legal complexities necessitate professional legal guidance to ensure they are properly drafted and enforceable. 


Fair asset division in divorce cases is a multifaceted issue impacted by numerous factors. Understanding them is crucial in securing an equitable financial resolution. By highlighting these factors, individuals can better navigate their divorce proceedings, ensuring a comprehensive and fair division of marital assets. 

Join the conversation!