·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Health & Medicine

Superintendent Slapped with Charges after Caring for Ill Student

— January 31, 2019

Superintendent faces charges after taking a student with strep throat to an emergency clinic and using her son’s insurance.

Casey Smitherman, an Indiana school superintendent, has been accused of pretending an ill student was her son so she could get him medical treatment.   She’s been arrested and charged with fraud, but the school board says she will not lose her job.

According to court documents that detail the charges, Smitherman, an Elwood School District official, relied on her son’s insurance when she was unable to get a sick 15-year-old treatment because she wasn’t his legal guardian.  The student was absent from school earlier this month, and she went to his house to check on him.  At that point, Smitherman decided he needed to see a physician for a sore throat.

“After making sure he had eaten, I could tell he had some of the symptoms of strep throat,” Smitherman said. “As a parent, I know how serious this illness can be if left untreated, and I took him to an emergency clinic.”

Superintendent Slapped with Charges after Caring for Ill Student
Photo by Banter Snaps on Unsplash

She was denied service, however, because the child was a minor and she wasn’t his guardian.  So, the superintendent decided to take him to another clinic where she checked the student in under her son’s name and insurance.  The student was prescribed amoxicillin and Smitherman picked up the medicine for him at CVS pharmacy, then took him home.

The student’s guardian contacted the Elwood Police Department on January 16 about the student receiving the medical treatment.  According to police documents, the student tore the label off the medicine bottle because “he knew it was wrong.”

Smitherman voluntarily went to the police station the next day to give her statement and indicated that she and her husband have bought clothes for the student in the past and helped clean his house.  She said she didn’t want to contact the Department of Child Services for fear he would be placed in foster care.

“I understand it was her desire to help a young man that was in bad shape, but probably not the best example to set for young people to assume other identities and make false statements,” Madison County Prosecutor Rodney Cummings said.

Smitherman was charged with official misconduct, insurance fraud, insurance application fraud and identity deception.

“I have been charged with three felonies and a misdemeanor, and I have cooperated with authorities every step of the way,” she said. “I am committed to this community and our students, and I regret if this action has undermined your trust in me.  From the beginning, my ultimate goal has been to provide the best environment for Elwood students’ growth physically, mentally and academically, and I remain focused on that purpose.”

The school board issued this statement: “Dr. Smitherman has tirelessly worked for the best interests of all students in Elwood Community Schools since she was hired.  She made an unfortunate mistake, but we understand that it was out of concern for this child’s welfare.  We know she understands what she did was wrong, but she continues to have our support.”

Smitherman’s attorney, Bryan Williams, said the superintendent would be keeping her position and has entered in a diversion program that will dismiss her charges if she doesn’t get arrested in a year for caring for the ill student.


Superintendent is charged with using her son’s insurance to help sick student, but she’ll keep her job

School superintendent faces fraud charges for allegedly using own insurance to help ill student

Join the conversation!