·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

News & Politics

President Trump Possibly Considering Return to Family Separation Policy

— April 8, 2019

Washington insiders say Trump is putting pressure on administration officials to crack down on migrants in the harshest ways imaginable.

President Donald Trump may be contemplating a return to last summer’s highly controversial and poorly-implemented family separation policy.

Speculation of the commander-in-chief’s policy reversal has arisen in the midst of Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen’s sudden resignation. Most media sources—including CNN, the New York Times—claim that Nielsen left her post under pressure from the president himself.

Even Fox, which put a predictably-less-cynical spin on the story, implied that Nielsen was a “poor fit” for policing the border.

The reason, writes The Hill, may be Nielsen’s resistance to the president’s long-shot and controversial proposals. Despite having abandoned the practice of separating migrant families at the border in June of 2018, Trump has purportedly considered reinstating it.

According to The Hill, Republicans fear Nielsen’s replacement may be quicker to acquiesce. Asked about border policy, Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) said that “one thing we all agree on now is families ought to be kept together as much as possible.”

Speaking to the outcome of a Senate confirmation hearing for Nielsen’s possible successors, Cornyn added that it “depends on who it is but it’s going to take some oxygen.”

U.S. Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielson at her confirmation hearing in 2017. Image via the U.S. Department of Homeland Security via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain.

Other conservative officials told The Hill that legislators from both sides of the political aisle will oppose a return to family separation tactics.

“If Trump wants to reinstate the family separation policy, that would be met with a lot of resistance,” one aide said. “If he’s look for a DHS secretary to do that for him, that would be a cluster.”

The rumors contradict Trump’s own words on tumultuous border policy.

“We’re going to have strong, very strong borders, but we’re going to keep the families together,” Trump said upon issuing an executive order to stop the same separation policy he’d enacted. “I didn’t like the sight or the feeling of families being separated.”

But Nielsen’s refusal to reinstate the policy appears to be the reason she was ousted from heading Homeland Security. Rolling Stone and ABC both note that Nielsen’s reluctance was rooted more in legal concerns than moral quandary—along with being rescinded by Trump’s own executive order, family separation was also condemned and ordered stopped by federal courts.

Democrats have already begun speaking out in concern.

“As a member of the Senate Homeland Security Committee, let’s be absolutely clear: I will not support a nominee who does not forcefully and unequivocally denounce this administration’s policy of separating families at the border,” said Sen. Kamala Harris, a California Democrat and aspiring presidential nominee.

However, Trump’s disagreements with Nielsen seem to have transcended the latter’s refusal to return to poorly-conceived and probably-illegal policy.

Late last week, during a high-level meeting in the Oval Office, Trump floated the idea of closing down the El Paso port of entry and then sealing other crossings along the U.S.-Mexico border.

One attendee told CNN that the president was infuriated after Nielsen panned the idea, “ranting and raving, saying border security was his issue.”

Nielsen reportedly tried telling Trump that if he were to close down the border, it’d only harm legal trade and traffic; persons crossing illegally would continue to skirt between crossings.

According to two people CNN says were in the room, Trump’s response was simple: “I don’t care.”

Along with attempting to single-handedly sabotage transcontinental trade, Trump demanded that U.S. agents along the border stop letting migrants in.

“At the end of the day,” another senior administration told CNN, “the President refuses to understand that the Department of Homeland Security is constrained by the law.”


GOP fears Trump return to family separations

Nielsen resigns as DHS secretary after White House meeting with Trump

Trump Wants to Bring Back ‘Large-Scale’ Family Separation

Join the conversation!