LegalReader.com  ·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Lawsuits & Litigation

Michigan Files Antitrust Lawsuit Against Mackinac Island Ferry Operator


— November 12, 2026

The lawsuit notes that, in the past, a number of different companies operated ferry services between mainland Michigan and Mackinac Island. Beginning in 2022, however, Hoffmann acquired a controlling stake in one of the last two remaining active ferry lines; two years later, it acquired the other.


Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel has filed an antitrust lawsuit against Hoffman Marine, the Florida-based company that operates every ferry service to and from Mackinac Island.

In a November press release, Nessel’s office accused the Hoffmann Family of Companies, owner of Hoffmann Marine, of having “unlawfully monopolized the markets for passenger ferry transportation to Mackinac Island and the long-term parking services essential to reaching the iconic destination.”

“Through a series of acquisitions, Nessel claims, “Hoffmann gained control of every passenger ferry line and commercial dock serving Mackinac Island, as well as nearly all long-term parking near the mainland ferry terminals in Mackinaw City and St. Ignace.”

The lawsuit notes that, in the past, a number of different companies operated ferry services between mainland Michigan and Mackinac Island. Beginning in 2022, however, Hoffmann acquired a controlling stake in one of the last two remaining active ferry lines; two years later, it acquired the other.

Greyscale image of Lady Justice statue; image by Ezequiel_Octaviano, via Pixabay.com.
Greyscale image of Lady Justice statue; image by Ezequiel_Octaviano, via Pixabay.com.

“Since that time, Hoffmann has exercised control over both ferry service operators, including their vessels, docking facilities, and parking lots, and has managed their operations through its Hoffmann Marine division,” Nessel’s office said.

“By these acquisitions, Hoffmann acquired unlawful monopoly power in both the ferry service and long-term parking markets essential to nearly all travel to Mackinac Island, and has used this monopoly power to raise ferry fares above competitive price levels, impose new fees, eliminate discounts and passes relied on by Island residents and workers, begun charging for parking that was previously offered at no cost, and eliminated consumer choice. It has, in the same time span, also suspended certain ferry services and terminated some customer benefits,” the attorney general’s office claims.

“As a result,” the lawsuit says, “every tourist, worker, and resident who rides a ferry to the Island must buy a ticket from Hoffmann, and most of them must also pay Hoffmann to park for the duration of their visit.”

The lawsuit also indicates that, in April 2026, Hoffmann threatened to end all ferry services to the island unless the Mackinac Island City Council agreed to extend franchise agreements on terms agreeable to Hoffmann; the extension would have permitted a significant increase in rates.

Margaret Doud, the mayor of the City of Mackinac Island, has since released a statement expressing gratitude for the state’s decision to intervene against Hoffmann.

“This was never only an Island issue. More than 1.5 million people travel to Mackinac Island each year, and many of them are Michigan families,” Doud said. “Over 80% of the Island is designated as Mackinac Island State Historic Parks, which belongs to the people of Michigan. The State has stepped forward on their behalf, and we are grateful.”

Sources

AG Nessel Sues Hoffmann Companies for Monopoly Over Mackinac Island Ferry Service

Michigan sues Mackinac Island ferry service over monopoly

Nessel lawsuit seeks to end Mackinac Island ferry monopoly

Join the conversation!