·  Legal News, Analysis, & Commentary

Verdicts & Settlements

Virginia Family Receives Settlement for Inmate’s Tragic Death

— February 6, 2019

Mentall ill man dies behind bars while waiting to get into a psychiatric hospital. His family is set to receive $3 million.

The state of Virginia, a jail, and the jail’s former medical provider have all agreed to $3 million to settle a federal lawsuit filed by the family of Jamycheal Mitchell, an inmate with mental health issues who died while in custody.  The agreement does not include any admission of wrongdoing by Hampton Roads Regional Jail, the medical provider, NaphCare, or other defendants named in the case.  Governor Ralph Northam had to approved part of the terms and it is unclear from court documents how much money each defendant will be responsible for.

24-year-old Mitchell suffered from bipolar disorder and schizophrenia.  He was taken into custody for alleging stealing $5 in snacks from a convenience store in 2015.  The man was then ordered to a state mental hospital.  However, his paperwork was found stuffed and forgotten in a hospital employee’s desk and the order was never carried out.  So, Mitchell died about four months later of heart failure due to rapid weight loss, according to a medical examiner.

A lawsuit was filed the following year, in 2016, by Mitchell’s family.  They alleged he was “beaten, starved and treated like a circus animal” leading up to his death.  Many family members were shocked when they eventually encountered Mitchell’s body at the funeral home.

Photo by Matthew Ansley on Unsplash

“I had to ask again: ‘You sure this is my cousin?’” said Jenobia Meads. “It looked like he was 67 years old.”

The family sought $60 million in total damages, and the lawsuit subsequently caused the Board of Corrections for the State of Virginia to take a closer look at all recent inmate deaths, starting with an investigation into Hampton Roads specifically.

Inmates reported Mitchell “paced naked in a cell often covered in his own filth.”  Family members said they were told he would also sometimes refuse to eat or take medication, and jail records show he “manically yelled.”  A report filed following the federal investigation of Hampton Roads Regional Jail determined the facility “is violating prisoners’ rights by failing to provide adequate medical care.”

Investigators found the jail was not adequately equipped to handle inmate health concerns.  It lacked sufficient medical staff to “treat a high number of physically sick and mentally ill inmates.”  The system, in general, is not set up to properly tend to those who with mental illness and they often spend months or even years on psychiatric hospital wait lists.

The issues echo those that are part of a class action lawsuit filed in Illinois, which claims the state’s “prison healthcare is grossly underfunded, badly managed, and deeply dysfunctional, resulting in needless, painful delays in treatment, mismanagement of common chronic conditions, and preventable deaths.”  Independent correctional healthcare experts conducted two separate evaluations of the medical and dental services available in Illinois prisons beginning in 2014.  The first report, released in 2015, “described profound, systemic failures in the healthcare system of Illinois prisons causing needless suffering and preventable death.”  The second report, made available three years later, in 2018 found “the system had not improved.”

Many of the deaths being reported in correctional facilities, according to investigators, could have been prevented with appropriate medical attention.


Newspaper: Settlement reached in Virginia jail death lawsuit

Man accused of stealing $5 in snacks died in jail as he waited for space at mental hospital

Family to Receive $1 Million in Inmate Wrongful Death Lawsuit

Join the conversation!